Statement & Argument

1:

Statement: Should articles of only deserving authors be allowed to be published?

Arg. I: Yes, it will save a lot of paper which falls short of supply.

Arg. II: No, it is not possible to draw a demarcation between the deserving and the undeserving authors.

A.

only I is strong

B.

only argument II is strong

C.

both the arguments are strong

D.

neither I nor II is strong

 

Answer : B

Explanation :

It is clear from the second argument that there is no way of identifying deserving authors. If the criteria of deserving and non-deserving authors are the signiicance of their articles, the question of investigating into the author does not arise. So argument I is weak and II one is strong.

Write your comments here:


Report Error
 

Option: A

Explanation : Explanation will come here. Explanation will come here. Explanation will come here. Explanation will come here. Explanation will come here.